Dehehantong represented a case involving mining-related duty-related crimes, overcame multiple difficulties and achieved a favorable outcome
Recently, the final verdict of a mining-related duty-related crime case handled by Zheng Chen, the director and senior partner of the Shanghai Enterprise Anti-Fraud and Compliance Business Committee of Dehehantong, was reached. The case went through the procedures of investigation, review and prosecution, first instance and second instance. The first-instance court changed the charge of theft brought by the procuratorate and instead convicted and sentenced it as the crime of abuse of power by personnel of state-owned companies. The second-instance court revoked the first-instance judgment, made a modified judgment for the party within a sentence range of less than three years, and determined that he had the circumstances of self-surrender. At the same time, the charges against some external personnel in the same case have been adjusted from theft to illegal mining. This case involves multiple disputes, including the determination of joint crimes between managers of state-owned enterprises and external illegal miners, the boundary of responsibility for duty-related crimes committed by personnel of state-owned companies, the distinction between theft and illegal mining, as well as the application of sentencing levels and the circumstances of self-surrender. How to evaluate criminal responsibility based on the specific actions, subjective intentions and scope of duties of different individuals involved in cases is the core of case trial and defense. The case ultimately distinguishes the nature and responsibility of the actions of enterprise managers and external miners, which has certain reference value for the characterization of mining-related crimes and the division of internal responsibilities within state-owned enterprises.
At the beginning of 2022, several outsiders planned to enter a state-owned mining enterprise to carry out iron ore mining and illegal mining activities. Relying on their previous experience of contracting enterprise projects and being familiar with the terrain and personnel, the outsiders approached the person in charge of the mining area, who was also the party involved in this case, and indicated that they wanted to remove some ore from the mine during the Spring Festival and asked him for help. The party concerned refused and stated that the mine management was strict and it was impossible to successfully pull out the ore privately. An external person threw several tens of thousands of yuan, indicating that he didn't need to take care of him, and then left. After contacting the person involved, the external personnel organized over 30 people from all levels of the mine, including the duty room, dispatcher, mine protection team, and production operation area. Eventually, they successfully pulled out more than 6,000 tons of iron ore from the mine and sold it. The client of this firm is the factory director of the mine, who is responsible for production organization, safety management and related on-site management. During the investigation and review and prosecution stages, the investigation authority and the procuratorial organ believed that he was aware of the theft of iron ore by external personnel in advance, which constituted joint planning and conspiracy. He was accused of committing the crime of theft together with the external personnel. Moreover, as the party involved was the person with the highest position among the enterprise personnel, the case had an extremely bad influence within the province and he faced criminal responsibility for nearly ten years. This case involves both internal and external personnel of the enterprise. There are differences in the behaviors and responsibilities of different personnel in organizing mining, on-site control, transportation and sales, and enterprise management, etc. The facts of the case and the legal relationship are rather complex. After the case entered the investigation stage, the party concerned entrusted Lawyer Zheng Chen to act as the defense attorney. Since then, Lawyer Zheng Chen has continued to represent the case, which has successively gone through the investigation, review and prosecution, first instance and second instance procedures.
After accepting the commission, Lawyer Zheng Chen started from the client's job responsibilities, the involved behavior, subjective intent and the relationship with other involved personnel, systematically sorted out the facts and evidence of the case, and formed a defense plan covering each stage of the litigation around issues such as the nature of the crime, evidence investigation, causal relationship, sentencing grades and the determination of self-surrender.
First, clarify the boundaries of responsibilities and distinguish the responsibilities of different subjects.During the investigation and review and prosecution stages, Lawyer Zheng Chen, through meeting with the client, presented defense opinions on issues such as whether the client was involved in the conspiracy of illegal mining, whether they were involved in the distribution of benefits, and whether they had a common intention to commit property infringement with external personnel. First, he emphasized that the client and external personnel did not have a common intention to commit theft. At the same time, he argued from the opposite perspective that the client was inactive. This case does not meet the criteria for constituting theft through inaction. Inaction and act crimes should be equivalent. There is no causal relationship between the party's inaction and the completion of theft. Meanwhile, the defense lawyer, in light of the internal division of responsibilities within the enterprise, relevant testimonies and management processes, sorted out different links such as production organization, on-site control and safety supervision, laying the foundation for further distinguishing the behavioral nature and responsibility scope of enterprise management personnel, front-line control personnel and external personnel.Second, conduct on-site investigations to consolidate the factual basis for case characterization. To further clarify the actual mining method of the involved iron ore, Lawyer Zheng Chen went to the incident area for on-site investigations to understand the differences in operation methods between using mechanical equipment to mine ore and directly transporting existing ore. On this basis, the defense lawyer, in light of the on-site situation and the evidence on file, analyzed whether the external personnel had carried out substantive mining activities. The relevant work provides factual basis for determining whether the actions of external personnel should be identified as theft or illegal mining, as well as for further clarifying the responsibility relationship between the client of this firm and the external personnel. If the external personnel can be identified as having a lighter sentence for the crime of illegal mining, the sentence for the internal personnel of the enterprise will also be reduced simultaneously. Third, propose a stratified qualitative plan to argue that the party does not constitute a joint crime of theft. On the basis of continuing the defense approach from the investigation stage, the defense initially considered the idea of evaluating only the party's behavior as a crime of accepting bribes. However, during the actual handling of the case, due to the fact that several other co-defendants exaggerated the role of the factory director and there were numerous external factors, it was almost impossible to determine a crime based solely on the bribery of a few tens of thousands of yuan. On this basis, the defense lawyer further proposed that if the party's actions constituted a crime, they met the constituent elements of the crimes of dereliction of duty by personnel of state-owned companies and abuse of power by personnel of state-owned companies. And provided multiple cases of similar behaviors in other regions. The first-instance court ultimately did not determine that the parties were guilty of the joint crime of theft. It adopted the defense lawyer's proposal for the crime of abuse of power by personnel of state-owned companies for conviction and sentencing, thus enabling the parties to deviate from the severe sentence range corresponding to the original theft charge.Fourth, an application for investigation and evidence collection was made regarding the evidence gap. After the first-instance judgment was made, although the first-instance court adopted the opinion proposed by lawyer Zheng Chen to change the nature of the crime, it still made a judgment of five and a half years in prison, that is, it applied the upgraded statutory sentence for this crime. Therefore, Lawyer Zheng Chen continued to represent the client in filing an appeal. During the second instance stage, the defense team continuously submitted defense opinions to the second instance court regarding issues such as the nature of the crime committed by co-defendants, the losses involved and the sentencing range, as well as whether the parties constituted self-surrender. In response to the key facts and evidence gaps in the case, the defense team re-examined the evidence on file, analyzed the relevant personnel and testimonies that had not yet been investigated and their connections with the nature of the case, prepared an evidence outline and applied to the second-instance court for further investigation and evidence collection. The second-instance court initially held that the case could be heard in writing. However, after carefully evaluating the factual objections and evidence Outlines raised by the defense attorney, it agreed to supplement and obtain relevant evidence that could reflect the specific mining methods of external personnel, further clarifying that they did not simply transport existing ores but used mechanical equipment to carry out the mining. The relevant evidence provides a factual basis for re-evaluating the nature of the behavior of external personnel. The case then entered the second instance court hearing procedure. During the second instance trial, the defense team, based on the supplementary evidence obtained and relevant legal provisions, argued that external personnel did not directly remove the already mined iron ore from the mining area. Instead, they used large-scale machinery such as excavators to dig out the ore from the mine, and then crushed the iron ore with a gravel crusher before pulling it out. This behavior constituted illegal mining of iron ore. It should be determined as the crime of illegal mining rather than theft in accordance with the principle that special laws take precedence over general laws. The second-instance court ultimately adjusted the charges against some external personnel in the same case from theft to illegal mining. The prison term for external personnel has been adjusted from twelve years to four years.Fifth, conduct a search for similar cases and argue the sentencing range. After the first-instance court determined that the party concerned was guilty of the crime of abuse of power by personnel of state-owned companies, it applied a sentencing range of three to seven years to him. In response to the disputes regarding the specific application of the upgraded sentencing standards, the defense team retrieved, sorted out and submitted the effective judgments of similar cases in relevant regions. They compared them from aspects such as the amount of loss, job responsibilities, degree of participation, degree of responsibility and actual sentencing results, and argued that the actions and degree of responsibility of the parties involved in this case were insufficient to apply the upgraded sentencing range. The second-instance court ultimately overturned the first-instance judgment and made a revised judgment for the party within a sentencing range of less than three years.Sixth, compare the confessions item by item and conduct an argument around the determination of self-surrender. The first-instance court did not determine that the party had the circumstances of self-surrender. During the second instance, the defense team compared each of the client's previous confessions with the first instance court record item by item, and sorted out the differences existing in their statements at different stages. After analysis, the defense team argued that the relevant differences were merely variations in the details of the statements and did not involve the main criminal facts. Therefore, the party's truthful confession should not be denied based on this. The defense team further proposed, in light of the criteria for determination reflected in relevant reference cases, that to determine whether a confession is made truthfully, the focus should be on examining whether the perpetrator confesses the main criminal facts. The second-instance court ultimately determined that the party involved had the circumstances of self-surrender.
After trial, the court of first instance did not determine that the party was guilty of a joint crime of theft, but instead convicted and sentenced him for the crime of abuse of power by personnel of state-owned companies. Compared with the statutory penalty corresponding to the initial charge of theft, the range of sentencing applied in the first instance judgment has been reduced. After the party concerned filed an appeal, the second-instance court further investigated the relevant evidence and held a hearing. It reviewed issues such as the actual way the co-defendants carried out their actions, the legal nature of the relevant actions, the sentencing level that the party should apply, and whether their confessions met the conditions for self-surrender. The second-instance court ultimately overturned the first-instance judgment, made a revised judgment for the party within a sentence range of less than three years, and determined that he had the circumstances of self-surrender. At the same time, the charges against some external personnel in the same case have been adjusted from theft to illegal mining.
This case involves different situations such as external personnel carrying out mining-related activities, internal personnel of the enterprise participating in on-site control, and enterprise managers performing regulatory duties. The handling of the case reflects the significance of separately evaluating the specific behaviors, subjective intentions, job responsibilities and degrees of responsibility of different subjects, and has certain reference value for the internal responsibility division of state-owned enterprises.
For criminal cases in the field of mineral resources, the crime of theft and the crime of illegal mining should be carefully distinguished in light of the object of the act, the actual operation mode and relevant legal provisions. The second instance of this case made adjustments to the charges against some external personnel in the same case, providing a reference for the legal characterization of similar mining-related cases. In addition, the defense team of this case conducted an argument on the sentencing levels for the crime of abuse of power by personnel of state-owned companies through similar case searches and sentencing comparisons. By comparing the party's previous confessions with the court record, opinions are put forward on whether the differences in expression in the confessions affect the determination of self-surrender. The relevant work has provided reference ideas for the sentencing and self-surrender defense of similar cases of duty-related crimes.