2026-11-10

Communication Between Defense Counsel and Public Security Organs During the Post-Arrest Investigation Detention Period

Author:Wang Yuanyuan

Preface

After a case is approved for arrest by the procuratorate, in addition to communicating with the suspect and their family members, lawyers have a more critical task from the case-handling perspective: communicating with public security organs. For ordinary cases, the post-arrest investigation detention period shall not exceed two months, though this period may be extended under special circumstances. During this period, recommended specific work for lawyers is outlined below.

01 Understand the investigation direction of public security organs and newly collected evidence

The criminal detention phase constitutes the preliminary investigation stage of public security organs. Due to time constraints, for major and complex cases, public security organs are not required to verify all alleged criminal facts; they only need to gather evidence meeting the standard for approval of arrest. In contrast, post-arrest investigation enables public security organs to expand their investigation direction and scope, and collect evidence as comprehensively as practicable. This may be interpreted as collecting all available evidence. The evidentiary standard for post-arrest investigation is to satisfy the standard for prosecution by the procuratorate, namely "evidence is reliable and sufficient".

Through communication with public security organs combined with client meetings, lawyers shall learn about the contents of interrogations conducted on the suspect during the investigation detention period, assess whether subsequent investigation directions have been adjusted, whether the investigation scope has expanded, and the status of newly collected evidence.

02 Understand the public security organs’ tentative opinions on case characterization

If post-arrest investigation directions are adjusted or the investigation scope expands, the charges against the suspect may change, and new alleged criminal facts or new offenses may even be added. Lawyers are advised to communicate with public security organs to learn about their evidence collection focus and tentative opinions on case characterization. Based on such information, lawyers may submit new defense opinions to public security organs in a timely manner.

03 Provide public security organs with evidence or clues proving the suspect’s innocence or mitigated liability

Where evidence or clues supporting the suspect’s innocence or mitigated liability are obtained, lawyers shall promptly submit such evidence or clues to public security organs. Apart from testimonial evidence, documentary evidence, physical evidence and other forms of evidence may be preserved by lawyers and submitted to public security organs.

Practices vary among lawyers regarding whether lawyers may independently investigate and preserve testimonial evidence. Drawing on our team’s experience and from the perspective of professional risk prevention, we recommend that lawyers refrain from investigating and preserving testimonial evidence. First, testimonial evidence is relatively unstable and may expose lawyers to professional risks. Second, judicial authorities in practice rarely directly adopt testimonial evidence preserved by defense counsel. Instead, they usually take witness statements or victim statements based on testimonial evidence clues provided by lawyers and record formal statements themselves.

Where favorable materials for the suspect are submitted to public security organs in the form of evidence clues, lawyers shall follow up promptly to track the progress of evidence preservation by public security organs.

04 Apply for bail pending trial / review of detention necessity after arrest

Seek modification of compulsory measures post-arrest

After a suspect is arrested with approval, lawyers may still take action to seek modification of compulsory measures. During the post-arrest investigation detention period, lawyers may file an application for bail pending trial with public security organs, or apply for review of detention necessity with procuratorial organs. The core of such work is to highlight changes in circumstances after arrest that render continued detention unnecessary.

It is particularly worth noting that, although procuratorial organs may conduct ex officio review of detention necessity during the prosecution stage, heavy caseloads may render such ex officio reviews ineffective in practice. Lawyers should seize this opportunity to explain to procuratorial case handlers the grounds for releasing the suspect from continued detention and submit supporting materials.

Specific working methods

Article 8 of the Provisions of the People’s Procuratorates and Public Security Organs on Review and Assessment of Detention Necessity stipulates: “Criminal suspects, defendants, their legal representatives, close relatives, defense counsel or duty lawyers may apply to the people’s procuratorates for review of detention necessity. When submitting an application, the applicant shall state the grounds for dispensing with continued detention and may provide relevant evidence or other materials if available.” Pursuant to this provision, for defense counsel applying for bail pending trial, supporting materials proving that the suspect satisfies the conditions for bail pending trial are essential, in addition to the written application.

Meanwhile, Article 13 of the same Provisions states: “Review and assessment of detention necessity may be conducted by the following means: (1) examining the grounds and supporting materials for dispensing with continued detention of the criminal suspect or defendant; (2) hearing opinions from the criminal suspect or defendant, their legal representatives, close relatives, defense counsel or duty lawyers; ……” It is evident that defense counsel’s legal opinions carry substantial weight when people’s procuratorates assess whether continued detention of the suspect is necessary.

Lawyers need to be familiar with the factors judicial authorities consider when comprehensively assessing detention necessity, including but not limited to the alleged criminal facts, subjective malignancy, remorse, physical condition, case progress, potential sentence, and risk of reoffending or harming society.

Judicial authorities may adopt quantitative assessment systems to evaluate detention necessity, setting scoring items for favorable factors, unfavorable factors and disqualifying factors, and referencing the suspect’s total score for comprehensive assessment. Lawyers may also adopt this approach and present the factors supporting the suspect’s eligibility for bail pending trial in a tabular assessment format to judicial authorities.

Conclusion

Where bail pending trial is not yet available, defense work by lawyers may help create conditions to secure such bail. For example, in intentional injury cases, if the suspect failed to compensate the victim or obtain victim forgiveness before retaining counsel, public security organs will generally refuse bail pending trial, and procuratorates will rarely grant non-arrest under the condition of clear facts and reliable, sufficient evidence. When handling cases, judicial authorities consider not only legal outcomes but also social effects, stability maintenance and restoration of legal interests. However, through counsel’s efforts, if the suspect reaches a settlement agreement and obtains victim forgiveness, the suspect establishes one of the grounds for dispensing with continued detention. With this new factor for judicial authorities to weigh on bail eligibility, lawyers shall file an application for review of detention necessity or modification of compulsory measures to seek release on bail pending trial.


Share